Good Ole Fashion Mac and Cheese – The Classic Comfort Dish

First, let me just say how grateful I am that you’re here, because this recipe is one that’s close to the heart. Nothing says comfort like a bubbling dish of homemade macaroni and cheese, fresh from the oven. It’s the kind of recipe that instantly brings you back to childhood dinners, Sunday suppers, and holiday gatherings.

💌 Want to keep recipes like this saved and ready to go? Subscribe to my email list and I’ll send the latest comforting dishes straight to your inbox.

Why You’ll Love This Old Fashioned Mac and Cheese

This isn’t just mac and cheese—it’s comfort in a casserole dish. Here’s what makes it extra special:

Creamy meets crunchy – rich, cheesy interior with a golden baked topping.
Family tradition – inspired by the kind of mac your mom or grandma might’ve made.
Simple ingredients – no fancy tricks, just pantry staples.
Crowd-pleaser – kids, adults, picky eaters… everyone loves it!

Anything but boring!!

What Does It Taste Like?

Every bite is creamy, cheesy, and full of nostalgia. The combination of sharp cheddar and gooey mozzarella gives it both tang and melt-in-your-mouth comfort. The paprika on top adds just the right amount of warmth, and if you’re like my mom, topping it with crushed crackers makes it all the more cozy.

Ingredients You’ll Need

3 cups dry elbow macaroni
4 Tbsp salted butter
2 (12 oz) cans evaporated milk
⅓ cup milk of choice
2 large eggs
¼ tsp garlic salt
4 cups cheddar cheese, shredded
2 cups mozzarella cheese, shredded
1 tsp paprika

Tools You’ll Need

Large pot for pasta
9×13 inch baking dish
Mixing bowls
Whisk for milk mixture
Cheese grater

Substitutions & Additions

Swap cheddar for Colby Jack or Monterey Jack for a milder flavor.
Add a touch of hot sauce or cayenne for spice lovers.
Use crushed Ritz or saltine crackers instead of paprika for a crunchy topping.
Stir in bacon bits, ham, or caramelized onions for extra flavor.